Comparison of book trojan war to movie troy

It is the legend of the Trojan War.

Comparison of book trojan war to movie troy

Comparison of Troy and Iliad - Essay

At times the film characters directly contradict the behaviors of their written counterparts, specifically in ways that are meant to make them more sympathetic to the audience, even though it comes at the expense While the film retains the enmity between Achilles and Agamemnon, and the causes of the Trojan war, it departs significantly in the way that it aligns Achilles and Hector with a more modern, melodramatic "Hollywood" attitude toward honor and honorable conduct.

At times the film characters directly contradict the behaviors of their written counterparts, specifically in ways that are meant to make them more sympathetic to the audience, even though it comes at the expense of the principles of the original story and our ability to believe the film.

In the Iliad, Chryseis is a Trojan woman given to Agamemnon as a spoil of war, but her father is a priest of Apollo, who calls upon the god to avenge the capture of his daughter, and Agamemnon is forced to return Chryseis. This hurts his pride, and he takes Briseis, another Trojan girl, who had been given to Achilles and was apparently perfectly happy with Achilles.

In the film, Chryseis is not featured, and while Briseis is initally given to Achilles, he has a single conversation with her before she is taken by Agamemnon, sparking a violent reaction from Achilles that seems wholly disproportionate to the investment he has, or should have, in Briseis. In the Iliad, Paris is said to be boastful, but cowed when he sees Menelaus parting the Greek lines to face him.

Hector reproaches Paris, and Paris returns to fight, seemingly at terms with his fate. Menelaus bests him, but Aphrodite causes Paris to disappear before Menelaus can kill him. Because the film eschews the presence and intervention of gods that is so prevalent in the Iliad, Paris is made to survive the encounter by means of Hector killing Menelaus, purely because Paris is "my brother!

We are meant to understand that the violation of the treaty, and the fact that this act will plunge Troy back into war, killing thousands, is less important than the bond of brotherhood or the fact that Paris proved himself a coward moments earlier.Comparison Paper on the Book Iliad and Film Troy On the Plot The plot of the book and the film has a very big difference especially on its coverage and focus.

The coverage of the film starts all the way from why the Trojan-Greeks conflict started up to the death of Achilles and the fall of Troy.5/5(2). Primitive War []: Analysing statistics in Lawrence Keeley's War Before Civilization: the Myth of the Peaceful Savage (). Table lists the Percentage of Deaths Due to feelthefish.com the 8 primitive societies that survived long enough to be analyzed by modern demographics, the median indicates that some % of all primitives, male and female alike, died by warfare.

Comparison Paper on the Book Iliad and Film Troy On the Plot The plot of the book and the film has a very big difference especially on its coverage and focus. The coverage of the film starts all the way from why the Trojan-Greeks conflict started up to the death of Achilles and the fall of Troy.5/5(2).

Sep 20,  · Watch video · The story of the Trojan War—the Bronze Age conflict between the kingdoms of Troy and Mycenaean Greece–straddles the history and mythology of ancient Greece and inspired the greatest writers of.

The Fall of Troy doesn’t happen in the Iliad, either.

Report Abuse

The poem ends at Hektor’s funeral. The poem ends at Hektor’s funeral.

Comparison of book trojan war to movie troy

Not much of a difference, I can see that Troy would be really strange if it didn’t end with the end of the Trojan War. The Iliad by Homer and the Women of Troy by Euripides are both Greek works of literature that look at the Trojan War from different perspectives. Book 6 of the Iliad illustrates that the ultimate glory is to fight for the city with no regard to the impact on the family.

Twentieth Century Atlas - Historical Body Count p.2